Hands, hold you poison or grapes? Pt. 2

Last week, I read a lovely post at Megan Nyberg’s Meditations about friendship, bracelets, Silly Bandz, time and loss.  And it made me think about Eva, a woman who was my friend for more than half my life.  We met on our first day of college, dorm-mates in a house full of wacky characters (yes, probably ourselves included, though we wouldn’t have seen it that way at the time).

Eva and I were friends through major moments: loss of virginity, first loves, first heartbreaks, adventures abroad, grad school, marriage, the birth of her first child, the start of my attempt to have a child …

Which is where the friendship ended.  Somewhere in the hell of my baby-making nightmare, Eva decided I wasn’t being a good friend to her – wasn’t keeping up with her as well as I should, wasn’t supporting her the way she wanted, wasn’t giving her whatever it was she had come to expect from her friendship with me.

Oh, I know that you, my gentle readers, will think, “Who could possibly be so mean to Stacie?  She’s so nice!”  And that’s very nice of you.  But I probably wasn’t a great friend during that time.  I was hormone sick and heartsick, sicker with each treatment, with each miscarriage.  I was a walking definition of “misery.”  So it’s easy for me to imagine someone not liking me much.  I have some redeeming qualities, but the fact is that  — even today — I’m really not all that nice.  There are plenty of reasons to not like me, plenty of ways in which I’m not a great friend that have nothing to do with hormones and childlessness.  There are ways in which I am a wonderful friend, too … but I’m human, and I don’t always get it right.

I don’t think any of the un-fabulous things about me justify turning your back on me when I’m at my absolute lowest point ever … and then charging me to call you when I’m prepared to be honest about all the ways I’ve failed as a friend (our last conversation).  I can see how random strangers might not like me, it’s harder to see how someone who knew me as well as Eva could let one relatively brief period at the tail end of a 25-year friendship send her packing. 

I thought my friendship with Eva would last my whole life.  There’s a Nigerian proverb that says, “Hold a true friend with both hands.”  I thought of this when I read Megan Nyberg’s friendship bracelet post.  Nyberg writes about friendships lost, about how it is that we can be so desperately close to our girlfriends and yet lose them, often without thinking about it, without noticing the loss immediately.  We wear our friendships on our wrists and toss them casually when the party-colored floss frays.  We don’t hold each other with both hands, even when we think we’re doing exactly that.

And I thought of that proverb and of Nyberg when I got an email from another friend telling me that Eva would like to hear from me, that I can email her at her job. 

I don’t really know what to make of that.

She wants to hear from me – presumably not so that she can continue to berate me for being a bad friend – but what, exactly, does she want to hear from me?  It is almost four years since we last spoke.  I have missed her practically every day.  I’ve cried over the loss of her again and again … But I’ve also been angry with her, with her inability to see that I’m not as awful as she seemed to think I was, that maybe I was in the middle of a really stressful, painful time in my life and perhaps what I needed was an understanding friend instead of someone pissed off because I wasn’t giving her enough attention.

I have no idea what to say to her, or if I want to say anything to her.  As I said, I miss her.  I miss her, her siblings, her parents.  I am sad every time I’m pinched or slapped by a memory of something we did together or said to one another or of one our foolish inside jokes.  But do I want to open myself up to her again?  Do I risk trusting her?  Yes, it’s only an email, not my heart open and bleeding in my chest, but really: it’s my heart, open and bleeding in my chest.

Did I hold onto Eva with both hands?  Did she hold me?  The answer seems plain, but is still hard to believe.  She was as close to me as a sister, closer than any other friend.  How could either of us have let the other go without a fight?

And what happens now?  I’m right back to Dylan Thomas, right back to the lines from the end of his poem:

Shall I let in the stranger,
Shall I welcome the sailor,
Or stay till the day I die?

Hands of the stranger and holds of the ships,
Hold you poison or grapes?


8 thoughts on “Hands, hold you poison or grapes? Pt. 2

  1. Hmmm a dilemma for sure! I’m the one who always makes the phone call to end the silence or sends the email to get a group together for lunch so I would say that judging from your longing to reconnect Imwould send an email. what do you have to lose? Ego? Hmmm

    I have a good friend who dumped me when she was low and I miss her but I didn’t. Get the green light so I am maintaining the silence, but I’m sure I would respond with a hi sign for someone connected.

    Break a leg Stacie as you begin a new school year



    1. Good question about what I’ve got to lose, Bonnie. I think that’s one I’m trying to answer as I draft and redraft possible responses. I seem determined to find some way to write to her, so we’ll see what happens.

      I know you’ve got lots of excellent writing activities planned for the new year, Bonnie. Have fun getting started!


  2. What a powerful post. I also lost a friend a while back for reasons that didn’t make sense to me, and I’ve often thought about what I would do if she tried to contact me again. For me the question would be, how much will you regret it if you don’t reach out this time? You’re absolutely right that it’s not only an email, but your heart out there. Is reconnecting with your onetime sister worth the potential re-heartbreak? If so, then do it; our hearts were made both to love and to ache. But if not, maybe send a message through your mutual friend that you’re not willing, at this time, to open yourself again to someone who hurt you this badly.

    Love and wisdom to you!


    1. Your question, too, is one I’m wrestling with, Lisa. How much would I regret not getting in touch with Eva? A lot. Clearly she is still very important to me, but I’m just not sure how ready I am to risk “potential re-heartbreak.”


  3. I miss talking to you. I’ve been reading, but consumed (like everyone else) and haven’t done much responding. But today’s post warranted a comment.
    I had a similar situation. A very good friend of mine, one who I would talk to weekly, share secrets, and joys, and hopes, and dreams with, stopped talking to me. She stopped talking to me when I needed her most; she stopped talking to me right after my husband passed.
    We spoke a few times and then nothing. I didn’t understand it. For months I racked my mind wondering what I did to offended her. What could I have possibly said, or done.
    Years later I contacted her. We talked-painfully at first, but then fell into our groove. she said that she was sorry for not calling and for basically chickening out. She said that she didn’t know how to be a good friend through my loss and was not sure how to comfort me. She felt like she needed to be more. I told her that I didn’t need anything from her aside from her friendship.

    I wish that we would not have waited the years in between; both of us wondering “why.”
    I am not saying that this is the case with Eva, but it just might be.

    So try swapping a silly band, perhaps she has one to offer as well:)


    1. Hi, Tisha! I miss hearing your voice, too. I’m trying to write my way through my hurt and anger right now to see if I can get to an email that will sound more like a silly band than a slap in the face. (Wish I had learned the whole write-it-out-but-don’t-mail-it rule while I was busy crashing and burning with The Morphine Man a few years ago!)


    1. It’s been interesting to read the responses I’ve gotten to this post — here, on FB, in my email inbox. So many people with broken friendships sharing their stories and kind support. I still have a lot of thinking to do, but I seem committed at this point to trying to make contact, so we’ll see what happens …


Your turn ...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s